Council bans free food service to homeless

19/Sep/2009

Comments: 20 readers have left a comment

Exclusive: THE City of Bayswater has ordered the Shopfront in Maylands to stop providing food to homeless and disadvantaged people because of a permit technicality, sparking fears the organisation could be closed.

The Catholic Church organisation is run by about 100 volunteers and provides support, friendship, refuge and up until recently, food to these people in the community.

The organisation also received regular food donations from local Catholic schools, individuals and charities.

About 1500 people visit the centre each month and the numbers have peaked in recent months as a result of the economic crisis.

City of Bayswater chief executive Francesca Lefante said the city contacted the organisation last week because it did not have approval to serve food.

“The Shopfront has planning approval to operate a referral office to direct their clients to support agencies that can provide help and assistance,” she said.

“They can continue to operate as a referral centre, but they do not have and have never sought approval to act as a meal and food distribution centre.”

Ms Lefante said the city received complaints from neighbours about abusive behaviour, including drunkenness, foul language and threatening behaviour associated with the meal and food service and the city had to address the issues.

She said the city expected The Shopfront to comply with the terms of the current approvals in the mean time.

“They can apply for approval to operate the service and the council would then look at whether it would be appropriate to allow the service to operate in that location and from those premises,” she said.

The Shopfront has put signs up on the windows alerting people it can no longer serve food.

Maylands MLA Lisa Baker said she was aghast at the city's decision to cut off the food service from the Shopfront.

“It is terrible that the city has done this without consultation or a transitional arrangement,” she said.

“I have worked alongside the Shopfront volunteers and the people they are working with are not vagrants - most of them are families in crisis or people with mental health issues.

“I don't know what the city wants to achieve by being pedantic over a technicality when it means cutting off food from the people who rely on this valuable organisation.”

The Eastern Reporter spoke to several people from the Shopfront.

However, while preparing this story the newspaper was contacted by the same people, who asked that their comments to be withdrawn and for the paper to contact the Central Catholic Media Group.

Bookmark and Share

What everyone else is thinking

Alan

18/07/2010

We all need help at sometme in our life. Be thankful that there are those in the community willing to put out a helping hand to our fellow human beings in their time of need. Let us not isolate the less fortunate in our society but show a little compassion and kindness instead.

Felicia

20/06/2010

I'm sad that hungry people are denied not only home made food but also sympathetic human contact. Remember it could have been you who are hungry .

what about the residents?

01/06/2010

What some people fail to consider is the impact these good deeds are having on the people who live in the area. Its all well and good to say they are uncharitable but you shouldnt be too hasty to condemn until you have experienced what they have to go through. I dont think anyone would ever say the program shouldnt continue, but what the residents are saying is valid and it doesnt mean they are uncharitable, they deserve our compassion too. surely there can be a solution so that these people can be fed without the obvious impact on the residents??

Richard

13/10/2009

Talk about red tape....just give the approval that's needed and let The Shopfront get on with the good work they're doing.

Luba

12/10/2009

We must help our "fellow man" who have fallen on hard times. You never know when it could happen to you. Hunger is the worst situation to be in. It's great there are people who care enough to help those less fortunate. Keep up the good work Shop Front organisers and may you be blessed for your kindness

Peter

12/10/2009

I'm shocked at some of the uncharitable comments left here, and am disappointed that some people would prefer to simply shun those less fortunate and push them further away from the nice, comfortable lives. I guess the phrase "out of sight, out of mind" fits - some people are content to not have any of the Real World bother them.

I just hope that if people like that are ever in that position, someone will still be charitable to you. it's easy to stand on your soapbox and judge people without bothering to understand them

Mark

25/09/2009

I believe Shopfront is located where it is because that's where the demand is. Maylands has many homeswest houses where many with disabilities, whether physical or mental or prison releasees are placed. There are a few hostels and a methodone clinic which bring those at the margins and struggling with addiction into the area. The reality is is that these poor people are there, whether we like it or not! To loby the government to move state housing out will be a huge battle. Let Shopfront provide the help these poor people need. Without the work these wonderful people do, crime may increase as they look for food and provision elsewhere.

Jan

24/09/2009

A community is made up of many people; the rich and the poor, those with good and bad mental health; the well fed and the hungry, those with lovely homes and those without, the homeless or with nowhere to go. Workers and unemployed. This diversity makes our community. I am a volunteer at Shopfront and to deny people somewhere to find assistance is cruel and selfish. Everyone needs a little help sometime. Don't be so selfish.

Tracy

24/09/2009

City of Bayswater took the action they did in respose to complaints by neighbouring residents about anti-social behaviour by Shopfront clients. The Shopfront provides a valuable service, but is in the wrong place, sandwiched between homes and business premises.

jas

22/09/2009

Homeless unfortunate people need help, after all they are humane just like you and I. It may not neccesarily be their fault they find themselves in the current situation. For god sake have a little empathy for those less fortunate than yourselves!

Timothy

22/09/2009

Cary - Nobody chooses to live the life of a vagrant, consumed in drugs and drinks. You're lucky enough to live a plentiful life and probably sufficient strong willed to achieve where you are today but not everybody is alike. By your comments, it is permissable in your world to banish the broken to another world so to make your neighbour prettier, orderly, bring up the price of your house while you live in your perfect world with white picket fences?

John van Voss

21/09/2009

As the City Council denies that they have stopped Shopfront from providing services, including meals, we'll just have to wait and see how the problem is going to be resolved. There is no need for those negative reactions from some of the people here.

Danni

21/09/2009

I often wondered what this shop"front" did, as vagrants galore converge to the area, making the place ugly, with rudeness, abusiveness, hiding around corners and sitting along the kerbing and pavements...making the trip to the station unnerving at best....let alone more breakins in the carpark opposite. I agree with Stu, we do not want this kind of person hanging around Maylands...at least get them to a community centre that has security & cameras, that can achieve the permits necessary, not feed them from an inner suburb street when businesses & homeowners are trying to bring the area "up", not lower the overall impression of Maylands. Thanks for outing the reason why the vagrant population to the area has grown.

Cary

21/09/2009

I think its great, we dont want this type of people hanging around our neighbourhood. Most of these people of drug addicts and alcoholics who choose this lifestyle, the sooner we get rid of them the better. The next step will be to close the methodone clinic up the street. These people have only recently been moved on from Northbridge and have taken residence here in Maylands sleeping under the bridge, down laneways and in the parks. WE DO NOT WANT YOU.

bel

21/09/2009

Charity breeds greed and dependance. Check out the 4WDs that turn up at places like this.

Martyn

21/09/2009

The inquiry to the City of Bayswater came in on Friday... the following forms part of a statement sent on Friday afternoon:

“I want to make it absolutely clear we have not asked The Shopfront to stop providing their services.

“I have personally spoken to The Shopfront and told them that the City does not expect them to stop providing meals to the homeless.

“The City has informed them that they do not have approval for the meal distribution service and that they need to address this issue.

“I understand that they are working to prepare their application and that it will be lodged with Council in the near future.

“In the meantime, they will continue to provide their services to the homeless....

“We have a good relationship with The Shopfront and have told them that we are keen to work with them for a good outcome.

“We are not sure where the suggestion that we want to close The Shopfront has come from, but that is absolutely not the case.

Stu

21/09/2009

Rules are for the guidence of wise men and the blind obedience of idiots

Caractacus

21/09/2009

Absolute rubbish, what right does anyone have to deny hungry people a meal, do the council crackpots want these poor people to go back to scavenging in my dustbin? Francesca ask Mr Magro to make the rule change and show some Humanity NOW!!

matteo

21/09/2009

i think its disgusting that anyone would need approval to be compassionate to fellow humans in need
since when was being kind something that needed a signature & stamp?
this shows a gross neglect from bayswater to look after its community

David Reynolds

19/09/2009

I think this is absolutely disgraceful, Shame on you City of Bayswater!

Share your thoughts in 60 seconds!

Members : login to comment